OPEN JOURNAL
D
Desi Truths
5 STORIES

Desi Truths

@desithruths
5 Stories

Affectionate satire, street philosophy, cutting chai, and the daily paradoxes of subcontinent life.

D
Desi Truths
Exhausted and unexpectedly proud
Hostel 4 terrace, Churchgate

What I Love and Hate About India

You know what gets me? The way we all pretend we're not staring at each other on the local train. Every single morning, same compartment, same faces. The woman with the red bindi who always sits by the window, the college kid with the oversized backpack who never looks up from his phone, the uncle who reads the same newspaper page for forty minutes. We all know each other's routines better than our own families. But god forbid someone makes eye contact. That would be a declaration of war or a marriage proposal, no in-between. Today was absolute chaos at Churchgate. Some signal failure or something, trains running twenty minutes late, which in Mumbai time is basically a century. The platform was packed like sardines in a tin, and this guy next to me is eating a vada pav with such theatrical enjoyment I wanted to slap it out of his hand. But I didn't. Because that's the thing about us. We'll stand shoulder to shoulder, sweat dripping on each other, but we'll never say "excuse me" without it sounding like an accusation. The hypocrisy is beautiful and infuriating. I was thinking about this while waiting for my cutting chai at the tapri near VT. The bhaiya there, he's been making chai for maybe thirty years. He doesn't measure anything, just pours and stirs and somehow every cup is exactly right. A businessman in a fancy suit stood next to a laborer with cement on his hands, both slurping from the same clay cups. For five rupees, everyone is equal. But step off that curb and we're back to judging each other by our shoes and our accents and our building names. It makes my head spin. The traffic circle near my place, the one that turns into a free-for-all every evening. No lights work, no one follows lanes, it's just pure instinct and horn-honking. But somehow, nobody dies. Or rarely. I watched a rickshaw, a BMW, and a bicycle all negotiate the same space without a single word exchanged. Just nods, hand gestures, a bit of swearing under the breath. That's India. We have no system but we have a system. We're all in on the joke but nobody admits the joke exists. And the cricket debates. Oh god. My roommate and I got into it tonight over whether Kohli is past his prime. Two hours. We argued like we were being paid for it, called each other every name in the book, and then ordered the same biryani from the same place and ate together like nothing happened. That's love, I think. Or maybe just Indian friendship. Hard to tell the difference sometimes. But here's what I really hate. The way we treat our own. The domestic help who comes to our building, she's invisible to most people. I saw a lady from the third floor yell at her for taking an extra minute to mop. The same lady who lights a diya every evening and prays for peace. What peace? You can't have peace when you're making someone's life hell for a floor that's already clean. The hypocrisy makes me want to scream. But I don't scream. I just sit on this terrace and write in a notebook like it'll change anything. The beauty though. The real beauty. The way the chaiwala remembers everyone's order without writing anything down. The way the local train, despite all its chaos, gets millions of us to work every single day. The way a complete stranger will help you lift your luggage without asking. The way we celebrate festivals like the whole country is one big family, even though we'd never invite half these people to our homes. I don't know what I'm trying to say. Maybe nothing. Maybe everything. I just know that living here is like being in a relationship with someone who drives you crazy but you can't imagine leaving. You see all the flaws, the corruption, the noise, the inequality. But then you see a kid flying a kite from a rooftop, or you taste the perfect vada pav at 2 AM, or you hear the train horn in the distance and realize you're home. And you forgive everything. For a little while. My phone battery is at 12%. I should go down. But the stars are actually visible tonight, which is rare in this city. The air is less smoggy. For a moment, everything feels possible. Then a train horn blasts and I remember tomorrow is Monday. Back to the grind. Back to the staring without looking. Back to the chai and the chaos and the strange, infuriating, beautiful mess we call home. Okay. Going to sleep now. Or at least going to try.

D
Desi Truths
Conflicted, amused, exhausted
My chai tapri, outside Anarkali Bazaar

What I Love and Hate About Pakistan

Same chai tapri, same cracked plastic stool, same bhutta wala three shops down. But today I’m thinking about how this country is basically one giant contradiction wrapped in a flag and a prayer mat. And I love it and I hate it and I can’t stop chewing on it like old gum. Started this morning at 7am because Ammi needed me to go to Hall Road for printer cartridges. Hall Road at 7am is already a war zone. Rickshaws cutting in front of buses, a goat tied to a motorcycle, some guy selling pirated DVDs of a movie that hasn’t even released yet. And everyone is screaming. But not angry screaming. Just... Pakistani screaming. Like we communicate at full volume by default. The chai wala shouts “ek cutting!” and the guy next to him shouts back “do cutting!” and somehow this is a complete conversation. No one is mad. This is just how we say hello. Then I saw this woman in a full niqab, only her eyes visible, haggling with a CD vendor over the price of an Atif Aslam album. She was winning. The guy was sweating. And I thought: this is Pakistan. We’ll cover every inch of our bodies but we will not be cheated out of fifty rupees. The hypocrisy is so layered it’s almost art. We’ll recite Quran on the rickshaw speaker but also blare Bollywood remixes the second we hit a traffic jam. We’ll judge a girl for wearing jeans but then spend three hours discussing the latest Indian drama serial. We’re all walking contradictions and we just... live with it. Abba called me at noon. He wanted to know why I hadn’t applied for that government job he sent me the link to. I told him I’m busy. He said “busy doing what?” I said “living.” He hung up. Classic Abba. He thinks the only respectable life is one with a pension and a desk in some air-conditioned office where you do nothing for thirty years and then retire with a gold watch. Meanwhile I’m sitting at this tapri watching a guy sell helium balloons to kids who will probably pop them within ten minutes and I’m thinking: at least that balloon seller is doing something real. He’s not pretending. He’s just selling joy in a plastic bag. That’s more honest than half the people in this city. But then the hypocrisy swings back on me. Because I’m sitting here judging everyone while sipping chai that cost ten rupees and using a phone that probably exploited some factory worker in Shenzhen. Who am I to talk? I’m just another guy with opinions and no solutions. That’s the national pastime, by the way. Opinions. Everyone has one. The chai wala has opinions on inflation. The vegetable seller has opinions on the cricket team. The guy selling fake Rolexes has opinions on foreign policy. We’re a nation of armchair experts. And we’re all wrong about everything but we say it with such conviction that you almost believe us. I remember last week at the traffic circle near Liberty. The lights were out. Total chaos. But then this old man in a shalwar kameez just walked into the middle of the road and started directing traffic. No uniform. No authority. Just sheer audacity. And everyone followed him. Cars, rickshaws, even a police van. For twenty minutes that man was the king of that intersection. Then the lights came back on and he just walked away. Nobody clapped. Nobody thanked him. That’s Pakistan too. We solve problems through pure street intelligence and then pretend it never happened. No system, no process, just raw survival instinct wrapped in a smile. I hate the noise. I hate the dust. I hate how nothing works the way it should. The electricity goes out three times a day and the backup generator sounds like it’s being tortured. The roads have more potholes than asphalt. The bureaucracy is a joke that nobody is laughing at. But I also love how we don’t give up. The chai wala still boils his milk at 5am even though he knows the power might cut. The fruit seller still arranges his apples in a perfect pyramid even though the first customer will ruin it. There’s this stubborn, almost stupid optimism that runs through everything. Like we know the world is falling apart but we’ll still make chai and argue about cricket and pretend tomorrow might be better. I saw a kid today, maybe ten years old, selling tissues at a signal. He was smiling. Actually smiling. Not the fake smile you see in charity ads. A real, dirty, gap-toothed grin. And I wanted to hate it because it’s so wrong that a kid has to sell tissues at a signal. But he looked happier than half the people in my office. What does that say? I don’t know. Maybe nothing. Maybe everything. Maybe that’s the point. We’re all just trying to get through the day and some of us smile while doing it and some of us don’t. Anyway. Ammi is calling. She wants me to pick up milk on the way back. The milk wala near our house is a fraud. He waters it down. But everyone knows and we still buy from him because he’s been doing it for twenty years and at this point it’s tradition. That’s Pakistan in one sentence: we know we’re being cheated but we keep coming back because the cheater is part of the family now. Phone battery at 12%. Chai is cold. Time to go home.

D
Desi Truths
Ambushed, affectionate, bone-tired
Kitchen floor, Gulberg, Lahore

Why Desi Weddings Are Beautiful and Exhausting

Woke up at 5am because Ammi decided last night that I’m the designated chai-wala for the entire wedding party. Not the groom, not the bride’s brother, not any of the dozen uncles sitting around doing nothing. Me. Because apparently my degree in “sitting on my phone” qualifies me to carry forty cups of cutting chai across a function lawn without spilling. And I did it. I carried them. Thirty-two cups in two trips because the first batch was too hot and I burned my thumb on the steel rim. Nobody noticed. The aunties were too busy arguing about whether the bride’s lehenga was “too red” or “not red enough.” The uncles were debating whether Babar Azam should open the batting or not. Same conversation they’ve been having since 2019. Nothing changes. The wedding itself was at some farmhouse off Raiwind Road. You know the type. Fake grass, fairy lights that flicker like they’re about to give up, a stage so high the bride and groom look like they’re performing surgery from a podium. The food was okay. The biryani had too many kewra drops. I ate three plates anyway because stress makes me hungry and weddings make me stressed. But here’s the thing. I was standing near the dessert table, trying to decide between gajrela and gulab jamun, when I saw something that broke me a little. The bride’s younger sister, maybe twelve years old, was sitting alone on a plastic chair near the back. She was crying. Not loud crying. The kind where you press your palms into your eyes and pretend you’re yawning. I walked over and asked if she was okay. She said her dupatta got caught in the door of the car and ripped, and her mother told her she’d ruined the whole day’s photos. I sat with her for ten minutes. Told her about the time I spilled chai on my cousin’s wedding sherwani and my Abba called me “a disaster with feet.” She laughed a little. Then her mother came and pulled her away with a tight smile. The girl looked back at me like I was a stranger she’d never see again. Which I am. Which I will be. That’s the thing about desi weddings. You spend hours getting ready, you wear clothes that make you sweat in places you didn’t know could sweat, you smile at people whose names you’ve forgotten, you eat food that sits in your chest like a brick. And then someone’s little sister cries because a piece of fabric got torn, and nobody cares except you and her and the chai wala who doesn’t even work here. The hypocrisy is everywhere. The same aunties who were gossiping about the bride’s “loose character” because she talks to male cousins were the first ones to cry during the rukhsati. The same uncles who spent the whole evening checking their phones during the nikkah were the loudest clapping when the dua was done. We perform emotion like it’s a script. We cry on cue, laugh on cue, get offended on cue. But when the camera’s off, when the dhol stops, we’re just tired people in uncomfortable clothes trying to survive until the next meal. I’m not saying it’s all fake. The love is real. The joy is real. I saw the groom’s mother hug him after the ceremony, and her hands were shaking. She whispered something in his ear and he nodded with his eyes closed. That was real. But the rest of it? The performance? The endless photo sessions where you have to stand with people you don’t like and pretend you’re a family? That’s the price we pay for belonging. I left at midnight. Caught a rickshaw from the main road because the Uber wanted to charge surge pricing. The driver was playing old Nusrat on his phone, the windows were down, the air smelled like diesel and jasmine from some garden wall. I leaned my head back and just let the city swallow me. Lahore at midnight is a different beast. The traffic lights don’t work but nobody honks because it’s too late. The chai stalls are still open, the bhutta wala is still roasting corn, the stray dogs are sleeping in the middle of the road like they own it. I got home, took off my shalwar kameez, and sat on the kitchen floor because the tiles are cool and my back hurts from all that standing. Ammi had left a glass of lassi in the fridge with a sticky note that said “for my tired son.” I drank it standing up, staring at the fridge magnet that says “Home Sweet Home” in Comic Sans. The irony is not lost on me. Weddings are beautiful. They’re also exhausting. And hypocritical. And loud. And full of people who will forget your name by next week. But they’re also the only time we come together as a tribe, as a messy, chaotic, ridiculous tribe that fights over biryani portions and cries over torn dupattas. I don’t know if I love it or hate it. Maybe both. Maybe that’s the point. My phone’s at 12% and I have to wake up at 6 for some cousin’s valima. I’m not ready. But nobody ever is.

D
Desi Truths
Resigned, amused, slightly bitter
My room, near the window, listening to the street noise

Things Only Desi Kids Understand

So today I finally understood why Ammi never lets me sleep past seven on Sundays. It's not because she wants me to be productive. It's because she wants company in her suffering. She was standing in the kitchen at six-thirty, grinding masala for the chicken, and she had this look on her face like she was personally fighting a war against the universe. I walked in to get water and she handed me a knife and said "Chop the onions." Not a question. Not a request. Just a statement of fact. Like the universe had already decided that my Sunday would be spent crying over a cutting board. And I did it. I chopped them. Because that's what desi kids do. We don't say no. We don't say "I'm tired" or "I have work." We just pick up the knife and chop. And then we listen to Ammi complain about how the neighbour's daughter got married to a doctor in Canada and how my cousin Priya is already earning in dollars. Meanwhile I'm standing there with onion juice in my eyes, wondering if my degree in "sitting on my phone" is going to get me anywhere. Probably not. But here's the thing. After the onions, she asked me to go buy eggs from the corner shop. And I walked past the chai tapri near the signal, and there was that old man who always sits there, the one who yells at the auto drivers when they jump the red light. He was yelling today too. But then a cop came and started shouting at him for being a nuisance. And the old man just smiled and said "Saheb, main toh roz yahan baithta hoon. Aap naye ho." And the cop didn't know what to do. Because the old man was right. He's been there for thirty years. He's part of the chaos. The cop was just a temporary visitor. That's the thing about this city. The rules don't apply to the people who have been here long enough. The chai wallah who sets up shop on the footpath, the vegetable vendor who parks his thela right where the bus stop is supposed to be, the guy who sells pirated DVDs under the flyover. They're all illegal. But they're also the city. And we all know it. We just pretend we don't. Yesterday at the wedding, I carried those thirty-two cups of chai. And do you know what I saw? The bride's father was standing in a corner, smoking a cigarette, looking at his phone. He wasn't talking to anyone. He was just... there. And his wife was inside, smiling for photos, laughing with relatives. But I saw her eyes. She looked tired. Really tired. And I thought, this is what we do. We put on the show. We smile for the camera. We chop the onions. We carry the chai. And nobody asks if we're okay. Because the answer is always "haan haan, theek hai" even when it's not. I came back from the shop with the eggs and Ammi was on the phone with my aunt. She was talking about how my cousin's wedding is next month and how we need to save money. But then she started complaining about how my aunt never helps with the cooking. And I wanted to say "Ammi, you're literally doing the same thing to me right now." But I didn't. Because that's not how it works. You just listen. You nod. You chop more onions. Later in the evening, I went to the terrace to get some air. There's a family two floors down who plays the same old Kishore Kumar song every evening at full volume. And I hate it. But also, I don't. Because it's the same song my dad used to hum when he was shaving. He's been gone two years now. And that song still plays. And I still hear it. And I don't know if that's comforting or just sad. Maybe both. I think that's what only desi kids get. The contradictions. The way we love our parents but also want to run away. The way we hate the noise but feel lost without it. The way we know the system is broken but we still navigate it, because what else can you do? You can't fight the whole world. You can only carry the chai, chop the onions, and hope that one day the chaos makes sense. Anyway. It's almost midnight. My phone is at 12% and I have to wake up at six because Ammi wants to go to the market early. She said "We'll buy the vegetables before the sun gets too hot." Which means I'll be carrying bags again. And I'll complain in my head. But I'll go. Because that's what I do. That's what we all do.

D
Desi Truths
Homesick but conflicted
Bedroom, Andheri East

My Hometown vs. the City I Chose

I got off the local at Dadar tonight and for a second I forgot where I was. The crowd just pushed me along, I didn't even have to walk. My feet were moving but my brain was still stuck in that moment last Sunday when I was sitting on the chajja outside my room in the old house, watching the neem tree shed leaves into the gutter. Ammi had made aloo parathas and I didn't eat them. She gave me that look. The one that says "you think you're too big for this house now." And maybe I do. But also I don't. That's the whole problem. So here's the thing yaar. I chose this city. Mumbai. I came here for a job that pays twelve thousand a month and a room that I share with two guys who snore in different rhythms. And every day I tell myself this is where things happen, this is where you grow, this is the real India. But then I go back home to that small town in UP for Diwali or Eid or whatever excuse I can make, and the moment the bus crosses the city limits I feel this weight lift off my chest. The air smells of cow dung and burning leaves and something that isn't diesel. The roads are empty enough that you can walk in the middle and not get honked at. Everyone knows everyone. The chaiwala at the bus stand knows I take two spoons of sugar without me even saying anything. And that's when the guilt starts. Because in Mumbai I've become this person who judges that town. I roll my eyes when Ammi calls to ask if I'm eating properly. I tell my colleagues "oh my god my hometown has like zero café culture, nothing to do." I post Instagram stories of Marine Drive and pretend the struggle is glamorous. But deep down I know the hypocrisy. I judge the small town for its gossipy aunties and its lack of opportunities, but I also secretly crave that same gossipy intimacy. Here in Mumbai, nobody cares if you come home at 2 AM. But nobody cares if you're sick either. The landlady won't bring you kichdi. She'll just say "rent date ko yaad hai na?" And the street intelligence thing. Man. I thought I was smart when I figured out how to navigate the Virar fast during peak hours. I thought I was a real city person when I learned to spot a pickpocket from a meter away. But then I went home last month and tried to bargain at the local vegetable market. The bhaiya looked at me and said "Mumbai se aa gaye? Ab rate nahi pata?" And he was right. I'd forgotten how to haggle. I'd forgotten the rhythm of that back-and-forth, the fake offended expressions, the "arey bhaiya itna mehnga?" I'd become too polite. Too soft. That's what the city does to you, makes you efficient but also makes you forget the raw street dance of survival that your hometown taught you. But here's the other side. The chaotic beauty. When I'm standing on the Andheri footbridge at 8 PM and I see the sea of headlights below, and the sky is that hazy orange of streetlights mixing with exhaust, and there's a guy selling bhel puri on the corner who shouts at a taxi driver and the taxi driver shouts back and then they both laugh. That energy doesn't exist in my hometown. The silence there can be oppressive. Here the noise is almost like a blanket. You can't hear your own thoughts but maybe that's the point. Maybe I don't want to hear my own thoughts because they're all about Ammi and Abba and the empty chair at the dinner table. I was at a party last week in Bandra. Some guy was talking about "curating experiences" and "mindful consumption" and I wanted to throw my drink at him. But I didn't. I nodded and smiled and thought about how in my hometown, we don't curate anything. We just live. We eat the same daal chawal every Tuesday. We watch the same saas-bahu serials. And we're happy. Or at least we pretend to be. Which is also a kind of hypocrisy, right? So maybe I'm just trading one hypocrisy for another. Ammi called today. She said the neem tree fell down in the storm last week. "Ab tera favourite aam bhi nahi bachega," she said. And I felt this stupid lump in my throat. That tree was where I used to sit and read old Tinkle comics after school. I carved my initials into the bark when I was twelve. Now it's gone. And I'm here in a city where everyone is a stranger and even the trees have to be imported. She asked when I'm coming next. I said next month maybe. We both knew it's a lie. The job doesn't give that kind of leave. And honestly, the fare itself would eat up half my rent. I don't know what I'm trying to say. Maybe nothing. Maybe I'm just tired. The fan is making that thak-thak sound again and my roommate has left the tap open in the bathroom. I should fix it but I won't. Tomorrow I'll wake up and do it all again. The train, the crowd, the fake smile at work. And I'll tell myself this city chose me as much as I chose it. But then at night, like this, when the noise dies down for five minutes, I hear the neem tree falling all over again. Phone battery's at 6%. I think I'll just sleep without charging. Let it die. Let everything go silent for a bit.

✦
Desi Truths
ALL CAUGHT UP

You're all caught up

You've reached the end of this journal for now.

Album artwork

Song Title

Artist Name

Music provided by Deezer